In thinking about the Elegant Cyborg one has to start asking the value in the data, that which we measure must have a value somewhere, somehow, mustn’t it?
That value does not have to be financial though, which of course makes the quantification of the perceived value difficult.
From the first sketches of the cyborg I can see the points of basic data flow from the individual and their activity, through the devices and onwards towards the stacks. To me, this does ask an initial question.
‘How useful is the data captured by devices such as Nike+, or Jawbone UP to me?’
From this initial question, I can add some further questions, to try and get more detail on this:
Does seeing the number of steps I take and/or data such as the calories burnt (estimated?) actually allow me to improve my health? Am I equipped with the right information to understand and analyse this kind of information properly?
I also have another question,
‘what is the value of this data to the Stack?’
Either on an individual basis, or in aggregation? How can they use the data to sell? (which is the primary use of data by the stacks).
In thinking about this at one stage I did wonder, does any of this information really have any value to the stacks? especially in aggregation? Or in fact is it really of use in creating a platform with share options, which basically leads to other sales of the devices (and a possible update path for existing users)? Basically is the real value in selling the device and general information on users sharing on the platform or is there any value in the quantified activity data from the users?
[I know, lots of questions and as yet no answers]